Hit or Miss – a pink too far?
This year has encompassed #MeToo and #TimesUp, the phasing out of Grid Girls and the publication of gender pay gaps; the battleground of gender equality is constantly gaining momentum. This leaves brands in a quandary, to overlook International Women’s Day looks stuffy, but by engaging with the day they open themselves up to debate on their motivation, and on their methods.
BrewDog jumped in a few days in advance of IWD to launch their ‘Pink IPA’, a temporary rebrand of their popular ‘Punk IPA’, which they said was aimed at countering the ‘patronising’ efforts of other brands to market their products to women. They perhaps had in mind here Doritos’ pilloried announcement that it would be designing crisps for women that had ‘less crunch’ and could ‘fit inside handbags’. ‘Pink IPA’ would be sold to women at a 20% discount, and 20% of profits from the sale would go charities fighting inequality and supporting women.
Whilst these intentions may sound positive, their use of a satirical angle, announcing the drink’s launch through twitter “We’ve created a beer for girls . And it’s pink. Because women only like pink and glitter, right? #Sarcasm”, caused controversy.
Many commenters felt that instead of critiquing sloppy campaigns aimed at women, Brewdog was just creating its own sloppy campaign. From this angle, Brewdog’s parody was simply too close an imitation of the truth. To a consumer picking up a bottle, without actively having read their press release, Pink IPA reads as just another silly pink product aimed at women.
In a culture where many genuinely sexist jokes mask themselves in supposed irony, an audience who might otherwise support BrewDog’s initiative instead felt the parodic style trivialised the issue, rather than enlightening it.
BrewDog’s response to the controversy thankfully avoided this defensive line, saying not ‘you can’t take a joke’ but “We’ll try to be funnier next time”. As they did have commitment to charity at the heart of their action, rather than a marketing ploy alone, they were right not to apologise for the intention, just to recognise that they did not quite pull off the execution.
As a success story on the ways to create something genuinely insightful for International Women’s Day tie-in, Spotify has joined with Smirnoff to launch Smirnoff Equalizer – a tool that enables Spotify users to map out their listening habits according to gender, and can suggest a more gender balanced playlist if you’re on the look out for one.
This comes as a response to Spotify’s 2017 Year In Music statistics, where only two female artists were featured in the top 10 songs and no women were found in the top 10 internationally streamed records.
The key achievement of this is that it directs listeners towards female artists, and ultimately champions the work of these artists, rather than that of Spotify or Smirnoff. At the same time, it also flags up the rich universe of data Spotify holds, as well as its increasingly nuanced and powerful playlist-making algorithms.
Smirnoff Equalizer has the potential to give people a real pause for thought, to consider their own listening habits, and to discover exciting new music they might not have otherwise encountered. The self-reflection element is a really key part – just like a quiz that says ‘Which cheese sandwich are you based on your favourite Disney song?’ people jump at a chance to find out more about themselves and their tastes.
As neither music nor vodka are strictly gendered, this campaign also doesn’t market itself to women or to men, a refreshing universality against a barrage of female oriented products leaping at ‘empowerment’ and often just missing the point.
Let’s look forward to the year ahead – where campaigners will continue to motivate for change, and where organisations can put their considerable influence behind sincere commitments to celebrating and supporting women of the world.
The future of payment – the revolution of mobility technology
Phasing out petrol and diesel cars and introducing EVs is a great option in...More information
Claire Brady on Net Zero Hero Podcast
Some people think that ‘circularity’ simply means recycling, but it is so much more...More information
Earth Day provides an opportunity to take stock of our progress towards addressing the...More information
When it comes to making sustainability claims, getting it wrong can cost organisations the earth
According to Robin Hicks, “2022 was the year that policymakers started to take greenwashing...More information
Less is more: How low alcohol brands are targeting their Gen Z consumers
Dry January may be over, but giving up alcohol definitely hasn’t gone out of...More information
Beyond B Corp: Breaking up with Barclays
Last year we became a certified B Corp, and to do so we had...More information
Three takeaways from the IPCC’s ‘final warning’ report
This week has seen the release of the latest IPCC report assessing the climate...More information
Why we’ve introduced a 4.5 day working week
As the rulebook of the working week gets rewritten, at Stand we continue to...More information
Stand shifts as we move into our second decade
I founded Stand with one simple (but typically ambitious) belief: that good comms can...More information
So… has the pandemic set us back or propelled us forward?
Last week, just days after the restrictions in England were lifted, we hosted our...More information
Wellbeing is not a one-size-fits-all approach
It’s safe to say that being plunged into multiple lockdowns across the past 18...More information
Covid-19 has given us a harsh lesson in education inequality
Although ‘Freedom Day’ is here, Covid’s effects will, as we hear all too often,...More information
The pandemic of inequalities
Last week, the Health Foundation’s Unequal pandemic, fairer recovery report made headlines, revealing that...More information
Has the pandemic set us back 50 years, or will it propel us forward?
At its onset, Covid-19 was described as the great leveller. But the pandemic has...More information
Pride 2021: Tokenistic campaigns just won’t fly anymore
June is Pride Month, a time for celebrating the diverse accomplishments, identities, and members...More information